Title: Convert Inactive L2 to Alumni
Authors: links🏴
Squad: links🏴, brianl
Date: Dec 2, 2023
Summary
This proposal seeks agreement to convert L2 members who have not recently engaged in Discord to a status of Alumni members, without Discord administration privileges. In addition to addressing security considerations, this will also make it easier to distinguish current contributors from past contributors, which is important during DAO-wide conversations.
Background
The BanklessDAO Constitution describes L2 Contributors as follows: “Level 2 Contributors (L2) are verified L1 Members who have also earned special recognition from their peers as valuable and committed members of the DAO.” Currently, the main benefits of L2 status is social recognition and additional Discord administration permissions (i.e. create/delete messages, create/delete channels, create/delete roles, and more).
The Constitution specifies how Members can gain L2 status, but not how they can lose it (except if they don’t maintain L1). It turns out that there are many L2 Contributors who no longer contribute to the DAO, but still have their L2 status. This is a problem, because it means there are many inactive L2 Contributors who have extended permissions in our Discord, which is a security risk.
The Idea: Use Discord Activity as a Metric to Prune Inactive L2s
Discord activity doesn’t actually prove you are contributing to the mission, BUT if a Member hasn’t engaged on Discord in a few months, there’s a high probability that they are no longer active. In short: if a Member doesn’t engage on Discord, it’s likely they are no longer contributing.
In fact, it turns out we have a TON of L2 Contributors who match this criteria. Some L2 Contributors have not posted on Discord for two whole years.
I did the math using the Ops Dept L2 Member List. Depending on the time frame….
- If we count the last 3 months, 82 of 177 L2 Contributors are inactive
- If we count the last 4 months, 72 of 177 L2 Contributors are inactive
- If we count the last 6 months, 61 of 177 L2 Contributors are inactive
Specification
- Create a new “Alumni Contributor” role in Discord which doesn’t have administrative permissions.
- Based on the vote below, move inactive L2 Contributors from the L2 role to the Alumni Contributor role.
Alumni Contributor Role would have the following characteristics:
- Must maintain L1 to retain Alumni role
- You can either be L2 OR Alumni, not both
Success Metrics
- # of people removed from L2 role (i.e. reduced security risk).
Useful Documents
POLL - Should we change inactive L2s to a new Alumni role?
- Yes, change the L2 status to Alumni for Contributors who haven’t engaged in Discord in the last 3 months.
- Yes, change the L2 status to Alumni for Contributors who haven’t engaged in Discord in the last 4 months.
- Yes, change the L2 status to Alumni for Contributors who haven’t engaged in Discord in the last 6 months.
- I don’t support this proposal (I will comment below).